The Apprenticeship Levy remains one of the most resented taxes on small and medium-sized enterprises. Employers pay 0.5 % of payroll above £3 million, yet in 2024–25 only 2.3 % of the £3.8 billion collected was actually spent by SMEs on apprenticeships (Department for Education levy statistics 2025). The vast majority of funds are claimed by large employers rebadging existing training or returned unspent to the Treasury.
For a small engineering firm or family-run care home wanting to train a young recruit, the system is a nightmare. The only approved routes are rigid, expensive “standards” costing £15,000–£30,000 over two years – far more than many SMEs can afford or need. A plumber who wants to teach an 18-year-old basic pipework is told the only option is a Level 3 Plumbing and Heating apprenticeship lasting 36 months. The result: 41 % of levy-paying SMEs let their funds expire unused every year (DfE unspent funds report 2025).
Large companies can afford the bureaucracy and long courses. Small firms – the ones that create most net new jobs – cannot. When they can’t use the levy, they stop training altogether, worsening the skills shortage.
The solution is simple and proven:
- Allow levy funds to be spent on any accredited Level 2–5 training – not just narrow apprenticeship standards.
- Include short courses, NVQs, technical certificates, and on-the-job mentoring.
- Let SMEs pool unspent funds with other local businesses or transfer up to 50 % to supply-chain partners.
- Keep the levy rate and threshold unchanged – no additional cost to the Treasury.
- Estimated benefit: £420 million more spent on training in the first year, with no net fiscal impact (DfE modelling of flexible use).
This reform would turn the levy from a tax into a genuine skills fund. Germany’s dual system succeeds because small firms get direct, flexible access to training money. Britain’s levy punishes SMEs for growing.
Stop wasting billions on unspent pots. Let small businesses use the money they’ve paid to train the workforce Britain needs.
The 1832 Club is fighting for these changes. The more members we have, the louder our voice in Westminster.
Join today from just £5/month or £40/year and help to support pro-SME candidates.
Together we can make a difference.